Customers keep coming back, but the brand doesn't spread

A business that sells well and has loyal customers, but almost no word of mouth: this is a sign the brand is working at less than half its capacity.

Sinh Vũ · Creative DirectorPortrait

Quick summary

When customers keep coming back but can't refer you to anyone else, the cause is usually not product quality. It's a brand name that is too hard to remember, or an identity too faint for customers to describe. For word of mouth to work, a brand needs two things at once: to be easy to remember and easy to tell.

In this article · 6 sections

Some businesses sell well and their existing customers come back regularly, but when you ask how much word of mouth contributes to new customers, the number is close to zero.

It's not that customers don't like you. It's that they have nothing to say.

Signs you are in this situation

Sinh Vũ often sees a few symptoms repeat in businesses that find themselves in this situation.

First: when you ask customers what the brand is called, they hesitate or get it wrong. They remember the address, the faces of the staff, the feeling, but not the name.

Second: when you ask customers to describe the brand to someone else, the answer is often “um, that place that does... that thing.” There's no specific word, no point of difference to hold on to.

Third: the business cannot describe itself in one short sentence without needing further explanation.

These three signs are not a marketing problem. They are a brand problem.

Why word of mouth doesn't happen

Word of mouth needs two conditions at the same time: customers must remember you, and customers must have something to say.

Being remembered is the job of the name and the identity. Giving people something to say is the job of the brand's character and what sets it apart.

When one of the two is missing, the word-of-mouth loop breaks.

A brand is customers' perception of a product, service or company, not a logo or a name.

Marty Neumeier, The Brand Gap

Research from the Ehrenberg-Bass Institute (Byron Sharp, How Brands Grow) shows that being remembered, meaning the brand comes to mind just when a customer is ready to buy, matters more than differences in product features.

To be remembered, a brand needs clear identity assets: a name that is easy to say and recall, consistent visuals, and something distinctive that others don't have.

+23%Average revenue of businesses that maintain a consistent brand identity, according to the Marq / Demand Metric survey (2019). This is a self-reported survey, not a controlled study.
The +23% figure above comes from the 2019 Marq / Demand Metric survey, in which businesses assessed their own results. Self-reported surveys tend to be more positive than reality. Sinh Vũ cites it to show a direction, not as a promise of results.

A hard-to-remember name is an invisible barrier

The brand name is the first thing passed along in word of mouth. If the name can't get past that step, everything stops here.

Hard-to-remember names usually fall into one of the following types:

  • The name is a string of abbreviations that can't be read as a natural sound (TMDV, HBS, ATC...).
  • The name uses a foreign language that your customer segment isn't used to reading.
  • The name is too long, too generic, or the same as many other businesses in the same industry.
  • The name evokes no feeling or association, just a neutral label.

When customers want to refer you but can't remember your name, they usually let it go or just say “I'll send the address later.” Most of those “later” moments never happen.

A blurry identity leaves customers with nothing to say

Even when the name is easy to remember, if the brand has nothing distinctive, customers have nothing to say when they refer it.

“That place is great” is the weakest possible referral. It convinces no one because it doesn't say anything specific.

Brand identity is not a design style. It is what makes one business different from another in the same industry, at the same price level.

Jenni Romaniuk (Ehrenberg-Bass) calls these distinctive brand assets: elements that, when customers see or hear them, bring that brand to mind immediately without needing to be named.

Without such assets, a brand lives in customers' memory as a blur, hard to retell and hard to point others toward.

50 millisecondsThe time it takes for a first visual impression to form when looking at a web page or brand imagery. Source: Lindgaard et al., Behaviour & Information Technology, 2006.

Two steps to take before renaming

When they recognize this situation, most business owners immediately think of changing the name. Sometimes that's needed, but it is often not the first step.

The first step is to diagnose correctly.

It's worth separating the two: is the name the problem in itself, or is the problem that nothing comes with the name?

An average name can still work well if it comes with a consistent identity system and a clear message.

The second step is to build a short descriptive sentence that customers can use to introduce you.

Not a slogan. It's the answer to the question: “What does this place do, how is it different, and who is it for?” If a business can't answer that itself in ten seconds, customers certainly can't.

  • Try asking three regular customers to describe your business in their own words.
  • If three people describe you in three different ways, the brand lacks an anchor point.
  • If no one mentions the brand name when describing you, the name isn't working.
38%Customers are willing to pay more for a brand they perceive as meaningful and clearly different. Source: Kantar BrandZ, around 2020.

What the way out looks like

There is no single formula for every case, but there is a sensible order to work in.

First, clarify the positioning: who this business serves, what problem it solves, and why customers choose it over somewhere else.

This is the part many businesses skip because they assume they already understand it, but once they try to put it into a sentence, it turns out to be vague.

Next, check whether your current name is fit to do its job. Not just whether it looks good, but whether it can be read, remembered, and evokes the right feeling.

Then build a consistent identity around that name: colors, typography and imagery used often enough that customers start to recognize you without needing to see the name.

The goal is not to create something “viral.” The goal is to give loyal customers a tool to pass on what they already know.

They already trust you. They just need the language to say it.

References

Byron Sharp, How Brands Grow (Ehrenberg-Bass Institute). Jenni Romaniuk, Building Distinctive Brand Assets. Marty Neumeier, The Brand Gap. Marq / Demand Metric, Brand Consistency Report (2019). McKinsey & Company, The Business Value of Design (2018).

Frequently asked questions

Why do satisfied customers still not refer you to others?

Satisfaction is a private feeling; referring is an action that needs language. When a brand has no memorable name and nothing distinctive enough to say, customers have no tool to pass it on, however much they like it. The problem is that the brand hasn't given customers a sentence to tell.

If a name is hard to remember, will renaming solve it?

Sometimes, but renaming is not the first step. First, understand why the name isn't remembered: is it too complex, too similar to competitors, or is the accompanying identity so faint that the name has nothing to attach to in memory? If you change the name without building an identity system around it, the same problem will return with the new name.

Does a small business need to worry about this, or wait until it grows?

Word of mouth matters most in the early stage, because it is usually the main growth channel when advertising budgets are limited. Waiting until you're bigger isn't wrong, but you will spend a long stretch growing more slowly than you could. The investment doesn't need to be large, it needs to be right.