7 minutes read

The branding process: expectations in the right places

Most branding project failures are not due to a lack of talent, but because both parties have different expectations from the very beginning.

Sinh Vũ · Creative DirectorProcess

Quick summary

A structured branding process typically goes through four stages: discovery and strategy, verbal positioning, identity design, and operational handover. At each stage, the client needs to provide specific input and will receive verifiable output. Understanding these boundaries helps avoid disappointment and keeps the project on track.

In this article · 6 sections

Most brand projects do not fail at the design table. They fail because both parties enter with different sets of expectations, and no one communicates clearly from the start. The client expects to have a logo to review in week three. The studio thinks the strategy will only be completed by week three. Neither is technically wrong, but both end up disappointed. This article explains each stage in a structured branding process: what the client needs to provide, what they will receive, and what will not happen at that stage.

Phase one: exploration

The first phase produces no imagery at all. This is when the studio asks questions, the client answers, and both sides check whether their understanding of the business matches reality. The inputs needed from the client include information about the industry, the target customers and the competitors. They also include the company's medium-term ambitions, and what the current brand does and does not do well.

The output of this stage is an analysis: market context, a true customer profile, and any positioning gaps that remain. Not a logo, not a color palette, not a typeface. If the studio skips this stage and jumps straight into design, that is a sign to reassess.

A brand is not a logo. A brand is the feeling in the gut of customers about your product, service, or organization.

Marty Neumeier, The Brand Gap

Phase two: strategy and positioning

Drawing on the discovery data, this phase defines where the brand will stand in the minds of its target customers. It also defines how the brand differs from competing options and what voice it speaks in. Outputs typically include a positioning statement, brand personality attributes and voice principles. Sometimes a brand architecture is included as well, if the business has multiple product lines.

What clients often do not expect: this stage can be lengthy and require the most rounds of feedback. Not because the studio is slow, but because this is where real business decisions are made. A wrong positioning cannot be saved by beautiful design. Conversely, the right positioning will make every subsequent design decision easier and more consistent.

38%The higher price that customers are willing to pay for a brand perceived as "meaningful and different." Source: Kantar BrandZ, around 2020.

Phase three: design identity

This is the phase most clients think of when they say "building a brand": logo, colors, typography, visual elements. But if the previous two phases were done well, this phase is really about turning strategy into a visual language. Every design decision can be explained by business criteria, not by personal taste.

A rigorous studio usually presents a single, well-argued direction, not three to five options for the client to "pick the one they like." This is not arrogance. Presenting many options pushes the decision toward the viewer's subjective taste instead of the objective criteria agreed on in the strategy phase. Clients pay to receive a solution that has been reasoned through.

50 millisecondsThe first visual impression forms when users look at a design. Source: Lindgaard et al., Behaviour & Information Technology, 2006.

The revision round is a normal part of this stage, but there must be clear boundaries. Revision means adjusting based on agreed criteria. Revision does not mean trying a completely different direction because the business owner suddenly likes a different color after viewing a competitor's Instagram page.

Phase four: system and deliverables

A logo is not the destination. A logo is the starting point of a system. The delivery phase includes extending the identity into real applications: business cards, packaging, digital interfaces, content templates, signage, uniforms. It also covers any other touchpoint relevant to the client's industry.

More importantly, the studio will hand over the brand guidelines. This is not a beautiful document to be filed away in a drawer. It is an operating rulebook that lets everyone in the organization use the brand correctly. From internal staff to external print partners, anyone can use it without having to ask again each time.

85% / 30%The ratio of organizations with brand guidelines compared to those that actually operate consistently according to them. Source: Marq (formerly Lucidpress) / Demand Metric, Brand Consistency Report, 2021.
Transparent note: The figures 85%/30% come from self-reported surveys by Marq (a brand content management platform), thus there may be bias from the provider. This figure reflects a trend confirmed by many studios in practice, but should not be used as an absolute statistical constant.

What is not part of the process

There are certain expectations that clients often have which the branding process does not include and should not include.

  • A new brand does not automatically change how the market perceives the business. It amplifies the existing reality. If the product or service has issues, attractive branding only highlights those problems.
  • The branding process does not replace business strategy. A studio can help clarify positioning, but decisions about product range, pricing, and distribution channels remain the responsibility of the business operator.
  • Speed is not directly proportional to quality. A project shortened from twelve weeks to four weeks usually means skipping the exploration or strategy phases, not that the studio is working faster.

How to practically use this knowledge in real life

Before signing a contract with any studio, ask directly: "What phases does your process include? What do I receive in each phase, and when do you need feedback from me?" The answer will tell you a great deal about how the studio operates.

Studios that cannot answer this question specifically often lack a real process, only presenting a process. If you find that there are more stages than you expected, that is usually a good sign.

+32 percentage pointsRevenue growth over five years for companies in the design leadership group compared to the rest, according to a study of 300 companies. Source: McKinsey, The Business Value of Design, 2018.

References

Marty Neumeier, The Brand Gap (2003). Byron Sharp, How Brands Grow (2010). David Aaker, Building Strong Brands (1996). Marq / Demand Metric, Brand Consistency Report (2021). McKinsey & Company, The Business Value of Design (2018).

Frequently asked questions

How long does a brand identity project typically take?

It depends on scale, but a full project from strategy to guidelines handover usually takes 8 to 16 working weeks of real work. Projects that run shorter usually do so because the discovery phase was cut, not because the process is more efficient. Cutting time in the wrong place often leads to rework that costs more budget.

What do clients need to prepare before starting their branding?

Most importantly, understand who your target customers are, what problem you are solving for them, and on which touchpoints the brand needs to operate. If you do not have clear answers, the discovery phase will help find them. Do not try to answer by guessing, as that is the job of research.

Why does the studio present only one direction instead of several to choose from?

A rigorous studio does not sell options based on taste. It presents one direction built from strategic reasoning. Presenting many samples pushes the decision toward subjective feeling instead of business criteria. Clients pay to receive a solution that has been reasoned through, not an internal survey.

Read more

The entire Practical guide section