7 minutes read

Who can use what: the structure of brand asset permissions

It's not a lack of rules, but rules that don't reach the people who need to know them.

Sinh Vũ · Creative DirectorBrand operations

Quick summary

When a business has several departments, brand assets get misused without clear permission rules. A permission structure defines who can use assets freely, who needs approval, and who is responsible for keeping things consistent. With this structure, the brand is protected without slowing down day-to-day work.

In this article · 6 sections

When several departments touch brand assets without clear roles, the identity drifts over time. Not because anyone does it on purpose, but because no one knows they are getting it wrong.

The problem isn't the documents

Most businesses that have moved past the brand-building stage already have guidelines.

But those documents often fail to answer the most practical question: “Do I need to ask anyone before using this?”

85% / ~30%85% of organizations have brand guidelines, but only about 30% apply them consistently. Source: Marq (Lucidpress), 2021.

The gap between “having a document” and “being able to apply it” is not a design flaw. It is a structural flaw.

Without rules that assign roles, everyone makes their own call. Different calls lead to different results, and the brand ends up looking like four different companies.

A brand's biggest enemy is not a competitor. It is thousands of small decisions made by people who were never taught the brand's logic.

Marty Neumeier, The Brand Gap

Three basic access tiers

A brand asset permissions structure doesn't need to be complicated. Sinh Vũ usually divides it into three tiers.

Tier one: free to use. Assets anyone can use without asking. For example: the primary color palette, licensed fonts, and the logo at approved sizes and on approved backgrounds.

Tier two: use with a check. Assets must be checked against the rules before use, but do not need to be sent for approval.

For example: internal document layouts, and social media images that follow the set format.

Tier three: permission required. Assets can only be used after someone with authority has approved them.

Examples: a logo on large printed items, a color combination outside the standard palette, anything going out to the public for the first time.

These three tiers are a reference framework, not a rigid formula. Smaller businesses can merge tiers two and three. Businesses with many branches or external partners need an additional tier for third parties.

Who is accountable: the brand lead

Delegation only works when someone holds the role of brand lead.

It doesn't have to be a designer. It could be the head of marketing, the communications director, or a person assigned in a smaller team.

This role has three specific jobs:

  • Answer the question “Can I use this?” within one working day.
  • Keep the brand asset library on the latest version, in one single place.
  • Update the rules when the brand changes, and don't let old documents circulate alongside the new ones.

Without a point person, every brand question goes up to the leadership team. That slows everything down and eventually leads people to just do it themselves to get it done.

71%71% of content teams say a brand asset passes through at least 7 people before it is approved. Source: Adobe, Digital Trends Report, 2022.

Conflict between departments: the real source

When the sales team uses one version of the logo, marketing uses another, and the events team adjusts the colors to "suit the banner", the conflict usually ends in blame.

But the root cause isn't attitude. The root cause is a lack of structure.

None of them know which version is the standard. None of them know whether they are allowed to adjust it themselves. There is no one they can ask quickly.

A permission structure solves this problem not by prohibiting, but by making “the right thing” the easiest choice.

81%81% of content teams say they regularly struggle with documents that do not meet brand standards. Source: Adobe, Digital Trends Report, 2022.

Asset library: one single place

Whether delegation works depends largely on where assets are stored.

If the latest logo sits in a director's email, the standard color palette is in a file sent to the printer last year, and the primary font is being downloaded from a designer's computer, then every permission rule is meaningless.

A trustworthy brand asset library needs to meet three conditions:

  • Everyone can get in when they need to, without emailing someone to ask.
  • Each asset has only one version in use, and older versions are clearly marked.
  • Include an update date so users know whether an asset is still valid.

The tool matters less than the principle of a single source. Google Drive set up correctly beats a complex platform set up wrong.

Delegation isn't about control

One easily misunderstood point: a permission structure is not a way for the leadership team to control every small task.

The goal is the opposite: to let everyone make more decisions on their own without getting them wrong.

When tier one is clear, the sales team doesn't need to ask anyone before making a service brochure.

When tier three is clear, the events team knows who to send a banner to for approval before printing, not after.

A consistent brand is not the result of someone standing guard all the time. It comes from everyone in the organization knowing what they are doing and having the tools to do it right.

A brand does not live in design files. A brand is how the whole organization behaves, at every touchpoint, every day.

Wally Olins, On Brand

A permission structure is how an organization encodes that into rules that actually work, regardless of whether someone remembers or forgets.

References

Marq / Lucidpress, 2022 Brand Consistency Report. Adobe, 2022 Digital Trends Report. McKinsey & Company, The Business Value of Design, 2018. Marty Neumeier, The Brand Gap. Wally Olins, On Brand.

Frequently asked questions

What is brand asset access control?

Brand asset permissions means clearly defining who in the organization can use which assets freely, who needs approval before using them, and who is responsible for updating the rules when the brand changes. The goal is not control but helping everyone make the right decision without having to ask again from scratch.

Why does brand identity still drift even with guidelines in place?

According to a 2021 Marq survey, 85% of organizations have brand guidelines but only about 30% apply them consistently. The usual reasons: the documents don't say who can use what, the approval process is unclear, and people don't know which version is the latest. The problem isn't a lack of documents but a lack of management structure.

Does a small business need brand permissions?

Yes, but in a simpler form. A business with ten or more people can already run into each department using different colors, fonts, or layouts. Start with a short one-page set of rules: which assets are free to use, which need to be sent to someone for approval, and one point person responsible for updates.