Keep the symbol, rebuild the geometry
The refresh after more than thirteen years coincided with the energy sector's transition phase. The letter P and color spectrum remained, while the change was in the design approach.
Change component(5)
- Symbol. The letter P is retained, redefined using modern geometric language with strong, stable, and flexible lines.
- Inspiration. The image of a person moving forward.
- Color. Inherits the traditional orange and green palette, refreshed and renamed as Energy Orange and Creative Green.
- Values. Heritage, Commitment, Pioneer, aligned with the philosophy of Collaboration.
- Context. Seventy years of development, announced as the energy sector is transitioning.
Read at the professional level(4)
- Reconstructing with geometry means changing the drawing method, not the drawn object. The letter P remains the letter P, but when constructed using geometric language, all lines converge to a set of radii and a set of angles. The result is that the reconstructed shape can be rendered in any size without distortion and can be cut by machines for signage.
- The roadside sign is a critical touchpoint. Viewed for a few seconds, often from a moving vehicle, at a distance and in various lighting conditions. In that context, only three elements are readable: color, outer shape, and contrast. Internal details are virtually nonexistent.
- Maintaining the color palette is keeping what is read first and from the farthest distance. Orange and green form a strong contrast, readable both in daylight and under lights. For a brand that relies on roadside signage, changing the color palette is the most expensive choice among all possible options.
- Renaming colors attaches meaning to what is merely a code. Two colors are inherited intact but are named as two statements. Not a single stroke changes, yet the meaning does; this is the cheapest scope in the profession and also the most easily overlooked.
Why change(2)
- The energy sector is undergoing a fundamental change, and a state-owned oil corporation must be able to say that it is moving in the same direction as that change rather than just observing. The 2012 sign system did not provide a way to express that.
- However, the main touchpoint of this brand is the roadside sign, viewed for a few seconds, often from a moving vehicle. In that context, familiar symbols hold value that new designs cannot replace, so the letter P and the color palette remain.
Within the brand system(2)
- A nationwide network means that the signs exist in thousands of locations where the corporation does not directly construct each one. Any system at that scale must prioritize the ability to be accurately reconstructed over the priority of refinement.
- Keeping the symbol and color palette is a decision to avoid altering what has already been established. With a system that has expanded widely, every percentage that needs to be changed multiplies the cost thousands of times.
Trade-off(2)
- What must be paid is the amplitude. Keeping the symbol and color palette means tying one's own hands, unable to create a visual pivot strong enough for everyone to see that something is happening.
- What is acquired does not require a recognition tuition. With a network spread across the country, the cost of retraining the market on a new symbol is much greater than the value of that pivot.
Professional assessment(4)
- Can be closed. Measure the viewing conditions first, then choose the scope. Very few identity changes begin with surveying where customers actually encounter the brand, and that very place determines how far the change can go.
- Change the meaning without changing the lines, by renaming the colors and establishing a set of values. This is a way to express a new statement with almost zero implementation costs.
- Still open-ended. A narrow scope makes it difficult for a single announcement to prove what it claims. The corporation states it is aligned with the industry's transformation, but what is visible is an almost outdated set, so the persuasion must come from actions rather than signs.
- The announcement uses entirely qualitative terms: strong, stable, flexible, without mentioning any measurable components. This page stops here.
Takeaway(1)
- This case shows that the viewing conditions determine the scope of change. Brands that customers spend time observing can change significantly. Brands that customers glance at for a few seconds must regain every percentage of familiarity lost through advertising. Before asking how to innovate, it is essential to measure where customers encounter you and for how long.
Similar case(1)
- Highlands Coffee 2022 Choosing to keep the old form and only redefine it, due to being constrained by the large number of sales points.
